RISK

Trading carries substantial risk of loss. Prop evaluation fees are typically non-refundable and the majority of traders do not pass first attempts. This comparison is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Read full risk warning

HEAD-TO-HEAD COMPARISON · 2026

XLtrade vs TradeDay

Side-by-side comparison of trust scores, profit splits, payout speed, and real trader reviews. Independent data — no sponsored rankings.

XLTD

XLtrade

TDDY

TradeDay

EST. 2022

XLTRADE

METRIC

TRADEDAY

44/100—

TRUST SCORE

BETTER57/100

2.5/5—

RATING

BETTER4.5/5

—

PROFIT SPLIT

80%

—

MAX FUNDING

$150,000

—

MIN COST

$99

—

PAYOUT DAYS

14d

—

PASS RATE

—

3—

REVIEW COUNT

BETTER4

XLTRADE DETAILS

STEPS: -phase

TRADEDAY DETAILS

STEPS: 1-phase
DRAWDOWN: Fixed
MARKETS: Futures
PLATFORMS: NinjaTrader, Tradovate, Rithmic
TYPES: futures

XLtrade PROS

+No data is available to identify any above-average metrics for XLtrade
+Placeholder pro due to insufficient data — see cons for context
+Placeholder pro due to insufficient data — see cons for context
+Placeholder pro due to insufficient data — see cons for context

XLtrade CONS

−No firm data was provided, making any meaningful comparison impossible
−Without metrics, traders cannot evaluate this firm against industry averages
−Lack of data is itself a red flag for transparency and due diligence

TradeDay PROS

+Min challenge cost of $99 is below the industry average of $186.7
+Single-step funding process is faster than the industry average of 1.6 steps
+Profit target of 6% is below the industry average of 7.9%, making evaluation easier to pass
+News trading and EA/automated trading are both permitted

TradeDay CONS

−Profit split of 80% is below the industry average of 84.7%
−Days to first payout of 14 is more than double the industry average of 6.5 days
−Max funding of $150,000 is well below the industry average of $839,272.7

PROPDNA VERDICT

XLtrade

Lower trust score (44/100). Slower payouts at —d.

START WITH XLTD