RISK

Trading carries substantial risk of loss. Prop evaluation fees are typically non-refundable and the majority of traders do not pass first attempts. This comparison is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Read full risk warning

HEAD-TO-HEAD COMPARISON · 2026

TradeDay vs Smart Prop Trader

Side-by-side comparison of trust scores, profit splits, payout speed, and real trader reviews. Independent data — no sponsored rankings.

TradeDay
TDDY
TradeDay
EST. 2022
Smart Prop Trader
SMPT
Smart Prop Trader
EST. 2022
TRADEDAY
METRIC
SMART PROP TRADER
74/100BETTER
TRUST SCORE
—73/100
0/5TIE
RATING
TIE0/5
80%—
PROFIT SPLIT
BETTER85%
$150,000—
MAX FUNDING
BETTER$800,000
$99—
MIN COST
BETTER$97
14d—
PAYOUT DAYS
BETTER7d
—
PASS RATE
—
0TIE
REVIEW COUNT
TIE0

TRADEDAY DETAILS

STEPS
1-phase
DRAWDOWN
Fixed
MARKETS
Futures
PLATFORMS
NinjaTrader, Tradovate, Rithmic
TYPES
futures

SMART PROP TRADER DETAILS

STEPS
2-phase
DRAWDOWN
Fixed
MARKETS
Forex, Indices, Commodities, Metals
PLATFORMS
MT4, MT5
TYPES
forex, large-cap

TradeDay PROS

  • +Min challenge cost of $99 is below the industry average of $186.7
  • +Single-step funding process is faster than the industry average of 1.6 steps
  • +Profit target of 6% is below the industry average of 7.9%, making evaluation easier to pass
  • +News trading and EA/automated trading are both permitted

TradeDay CONS

  • −Profit split of 80% is below the industry average of 84.7%
  • −Days to first payout of 14 is more than double the industry average of 6.5 days
  • −Max funding of $150,000 is well below the industry average of $839,272.7

Smart Prop Trader PROS

  • +Profit split of 85% is above the industry average of 84.7%.
  • +Minimum challenge cost of $97 is well below the industry average of $186.7.
  • +On-demand payouts, weekend holding, news trading, and EA use are all permitted.
  • +Supports multiple platforms including MT4 and MT5.

Smart Prop Trader CONS

  • −Max funding of $800,000 is slightly below the industry average of $839,272.7.
  • −Days to first payout of 7 is marginally above the industry average of 6.5 days.
  • −No fee refund offered, adding cost risk for traders who do not pass the challenge.

PROPDNA VERDICT

TradeDay
Higher trust score (74/100). Slower payouts at 14d. 80% profit split.
Smart Prop Trader
Lower trust score (73/100). Faster payouts at 7d. 85% profit split.

RELATED LINKS

TradeDay Full Review →Smart Prop Trader Full Review →All Comparisons →
← COMPARE ALL FIRMS ON PROPDNA

Affiliate disclosure: PropDNA may earn a commission if you start a challenge through links on this page. Scores are calculated algorithmically from verified trader reviews — not influenced by commercial relationships.Privacy Policy